Referee Muhammad Usaid Jamal mistakenly sent off Jaime Rosquillo instead of Noah Leddel during Vietnams 2-1 win over the Philippines in the AFF U23 2025 semi-final.
Referee Sends Off Wrong Player in Vietnam's 2-1 Win Over Philippines
In a dramatic ending to the semi-final of the 2025 AFF U23 Championship, referee Muhammad Usaid Jamal mistakenly sent off the wrong player from the Philippines during their 1-2 loss to Vietnam at Crickex Gelora Bung Karno Stadium in Indonesia on July 25, 2025.
Controversial Red Card in AFF U23 Championship 2025 Semi-Final
In the fifth minute of second-half injury time, Nguyen Quoc Viet sprinted through the center of the Philippines defense, positioned between Noah Leddel and Jaime Rosquillo. As he approached the penalty area, he was fouled and lost his chance to go one-on-one with the goalkeeper. Referee Jamal then issued a straight red card to Rosquillo, who wore the number 14 shirt.
However, replays clearly showed that Leddel (number 2) was the actual offender, grabbing Quoc Viets arm and pulling him down. The decision sparked controversy as Rosquillo was not involved in the foul.
Introduction to Crickex
P95 Red Card Mistake
After all three players fell to the ground through Cricket Login Guide, the referee approached slowly. Broadcast footage captured Leddel's anxious expression, waiting for the referees decision. To the surprise of many, Jamal pointed to Rosquillo and showed him the red card. Born in 2003, Rosquillo looked confused but accepted the decision and walked off the pitch. Leddel remained on the field and played until the final whistle.
As the AFF U23 Championship 2025 does not use VAR (Video Assistant Referee), the referees decisions on the field are final. However, the Philippine Football Federation has the right to appeal the red card to the ASEAN Football Federation (AFF) to ensure the correct player is held accountable.
Step-by-Step Crickex Login Guide for 2025
The Philippines will still compete in the third-place playoff on July 28, against the loser of the other semi-final between Indonesia and Thailand.
Similar Incidents in Football History
This is not the first time such a mistake has occurred in professional football. In the 2014 English Premier League, referee Andre Marriner sent off Kieran Gibbs of Arsenal by mistake, when it was Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain who committed the handball in a match against Chelsea. Marriner later admitted the error. The FA rescinded the red card for Chamberlain, but did not reassign the punishment to Gibbs as the foul wasnt deemed worthy of a red card.
Crickex offers a diverse range of gaming options
At the 2022 AFC U23 Championship group stage in Uzbekistan, referee Ahmad Alali almost made a similar error in a match between Vietnam and South Korea. In the 78th minute, a Vietnamese player was fouled outside the box. The referee gave a yellow card to Lee Sang-min, but after VAR intervention, the card was withdrawn and instead shown to Lee Jin-yong, who had already received a yellow. As a result, South Korea had to play with 10 men.
Conclusion
Referee errors like this, though rare, can have a significant impact on crucial matches. The Philippines' coaching staff may file an appeal to correct the record, but the incident highlights the growing need for VAR implementation in regional tournaments like the AFF U23 Championship. Without video assistance, teams remain vulnerable to human error, even on the biggest stage.
